As part of the research mentoring team, you are assigned to assess a short research proposal that a team of youth researchers has submitted to undertake within a period of two months.
Read through the following short excerpt from their research proposal and develop a risk assessment matrix to identify issues concerning ethics and project impact, recommending corrective actions and protocols, using the template provided.
Studying the Prevalence and Impact of Bullying on Mental Health and Academic Performance of School Children in Lahore, Pakistan
Background
Bullying is one of the most prevalent forms of “school-based” violence; defined as “intentional repeated overt or covert inappropriate behaviour from another that is intended to intimidate and harm the target”. Victims of bullying in schools that are repeatedly exposed to this violence overtime develop a number of emotional disorders (like higher risk of depression, suicidal ideation, anxiety, sleep disturbances, social isolation and feelings of loneliness), eventually severely impacting the academic performance of the said youth and adolescents as well. Through the current study the research team aims to study the prevalence of bullying in schools of Lahore and understand its causal link with educational performance and mental health issues among school-going children.
Materials and Methods
In order to gather information on the prevalence and impact of bullying the research tea, aims to select ten schools in Lahore. The researchers will choose a representative sample from students in grades 7 to 9, of 150 students per school (age ranging from 12 to 15 years old). The research will be broken down into the following phases:
Phase I: Information on prevalence of bullying in the schools
The research team will carry-out survey of the selected schools:
The students will be asked how many times they have been bullied in the academic session (weekly, monthly, never), and the type of bullying they faced (e.g., I was made fun of, or called names/I was hit or hurt by other students/I was made to do things I didn’t consent to doing, etc.).
Phase II: Academic Performance Tests
The research team will conduct academic performance tests, which will include a 1-hour test; including a reading test, a standardized maths test, and a creative thinking test.
Phase III: Face-to-face interviews assessing the mental health outcomes of bullying
In the last phase the research team will be undertaking face-to-face interview of school children that have been bullied, the researchers will be recording the interviews in audio (to not reveal their faces).
Following is a sample questionnaire the researchers intends to use.
- During the past academic session, how often have you felt lonely?
- During the past academic session, how often have you been worried so much that you couldn’t sleep at night?
- During the past academic session , did you ever seriously consider attempting suicide?
- During the past academic session, how many times did you actually attempt suicide?
- During the past academic session, how many times were you involved in a physical fight?
- During the past academic year how, many days have you missed school because you felt unsafe to show up to school?
- During the past academic year how, many times did you miss classes or school without permission?
- During the past academic session how, many times were you bullied, and can you tell us how you were bullied?
- Why do you think some kids are bullies?
- Have you ever bullied others?
- What do the adults in your institution respond when they see bullying?
- Have you talked to anyone about being bullied? (Parents, teachers, others).
Partially adapted from:
Correlates of bullying victimization among school adolescents in Nepal: Findings from 2015 Global School-Based Student Health Survey Nepal Neupane T, Pandey AR, Bista B, Chalise B (2020) Correlates of bullying victimization among school adolescents in Nepal: Findings from 2015 Global School-Based Student Health Survey Nepal. PLOS ONE 15(8): e0237406. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0237406
Question Pro: Bullying Survey for Students Questions + Sample Questionnaire Template:
https://www.questionpro.com/survey-templates/bullying-for-students-survey-template/